Via Integra

Fr Mark's progressive Anglo-Catholic take on European Christianity

  • This is my collection of material about the current state of the churches in Europe. I am interested in looking at how they are dealing with the pressing issues of our time: the issues of gay people and women in ministry/ leadership are particularly pressing at the moment, as is the area of declining church attendance.

    I would like to see how Europe's traditional religious institutions are coping with the new Europe currently being forged, in which public opinion and ethical attitudes are becoming inceasingly pan-European, and are evidently presenting a series of strong challenges for the churches.

Portugal – the gay issue

Posted by Fr Mark on August 15, 2009


503px-Coat_of_arms_of_Portugal_svgInterestingly, the Secretary of the Roman Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Portugal has come out in favour of civil partnerships for gay couples, by adopting an “anything but full marriage” argument.



From Edge, 01.02.09:


The leader of Portugal’s ruling Socialist Party, Jose Socrates, has announced that he support gay marriage. According to Life Site News, a conservative religious “news” site, the announcements has set off a firestorm in the country, which remains fairly conservative and with a majority of practicing Roman Catholics, despite electing a socialist party.

“This is the moment for the PS, in its national congress, to affirm its desire to propose to Portuguese society the right to civil marriage for people of the same sex,” Socrates told a rally. “As far as I know, after doing this in our country, we won’t be the last to do so. I also want to say that the values that inspire us when we propose this change to the Portuguese people are the values that have always been in the heart of the PS.”

“Homosexual marriages are complicated questions of conscience,” said Mario Soares, the former president of Portugal and a founder of the Socialist Party, in response to Socrates’ comments. “But there are certain radicals who want to move forward [with it] to show that they are leftist.” Soares implied that the government should be concentrating on the problems that deal with “work, workers and unions.”

“In my opinion and the opinion of young socialists, [Mario Soares] is deceived,” countered Socialist Youth leader Duarte Cordeiro. “It’s a fundamental issue for the left and I don’t think it is radicalism.”

Perhaps not altogether unexpectedly the church didn’t waste any time reacting to the call. The secretary of the Catholic Episcopal Conference of Portugal, P. Manuel Morujao, however, somewhat surprisingly objected only weakly to the proposal.

The Catholic cleric and leader even advocated that gay unions be legalized as they are in Britain, but without the name “marriage” attached to them. “Our structural identity is a value to cultivate,” wrote Morujao. “Identity is not question of choice. I am not a man or a women by choice. I am also my body and with it I must deepen my psychological, affective, and relational identity. It seems to me a serious anthropological error to equalize a homosexual union with marriage and family.”

He approvingly cited Britain’s “legal framework for a stable union between two people of the same sex, with certain rights, for example at the level of taxes and inheritance. Do all of that,” he added, “but without giving the name and the status of ’marriage’ and ’family.’”

Life Site News reported that Morujao’s response was “less than satisfying to Portugal’s many Catholics.”

“The teaching of the Catholic Church officially condemns homosexual sexual relations as intrinsically evil, and homosexual attraction as an intrinsic disorder,” according to the site. Maybe so, but apparently the Portuguese church is thinking a bit differently these days.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: